Fernhart Labs.

Water bath vs pressure canning: which foods need which

Short answer

Low-acid foods (all vegetables, meat, poultry, seafood and soups) must be pressure canned: only a pressure canner gets hot enough to destroy the spores of *Clostridium botulinum* in them. The USDA guide gives no water-bath time for any of them, so green beans, potatoes and corn can't be water-bath canned.

Fruits and acidified tomatoes can go in a boiling-water bath, and many also have a tested pressure-canner option at lower pressures. Use the time for the method you choose; never move a time from one method to the other.

Which canner the guide gives, by kind of food

Counted from the guide's own tables (the build checks that no low-acid food has a water-bath time).

Which canner the USDA guide gives, by kind of food
Kind of foodFoods in the guideLow-acidCanner the guide gives
Vegetables1919Pressure canner only
Meat and poultry66Pressure canner only
Seafood77Pressure canner only
Soups22Pressure canner only
Tomatoes81Water bath for 7 of 8; a pressure option for 8 of 8
Tomato sauces83Water bath for 5 of 8; a pressure option for 3 of 8
Fruit160Water bath for 16 of 16; a pressure option for 10 of 16
Fruit juices20Water bath only

Counted from the USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning (2015) tables as transcribed in Jarwise. Low-acid foods never get a water-bath time.

How the two methods differ

  • Boiling-water bath: jars covered by at least 1 inch of water (2 inches for processes over 30 minutes), timed from a full rolling boil with the lid on. If the boil stops, bring it back and time the whole process again. When done, turn off the heat, take the lid off and wait 5 minutes before lifting the jars out (Guide 1, page 1-18).
  • Pressure canner: 2 to 3 inches of water, vent steam for 10 minutes, then time at the pressure for your altitude and gauge. If the pressure drops below it, bring it back and time the whole process again. Let the canner come down to zero on its own (Guide 1, pages 1-20 and 1-21).
  • Altitude: both methods change with altitude, the water bath by longer times, the pressure canner by higher pressure (Guide 1, page 1-22).

Why low-acid foods need pressure

Botulinum spores survive the temperature of boiling water. In the sealed, airless jar of a low-acid food they can grow and make toxin. A pressure canner raises the temperature enough to destroy them in the tested time. That's why the guide gives low-acid foods pressure-canner times only, and why tomatoes need added acid even in a water bath (Introduction; Guide 1, page 1-8).

Methods the guide warns against

Open-kettle canning (filling hot jars without processing them) and processing jars in an oven, a microwave or a dishwasher don't prevent all risks. Use a boiling-water or pressure canner with a tested time (Guide 1, page 1-10).

Questions

Can you water bath green beans?

No. Green beans are a low-acid vegetable; the USDA guide gives them pressure-canner times only (20 minutes for pints, 25 for quarts).

Can you water bath potatoes or corn?

No. Like all vegetables they are low-acid and must be pressure canned with a tested time.

Can you pressure can tomatoes instead of using a water bath?

Yes. The guide tests pressure-canner options for several tomato products at lower pressures, with acid still added to every jar.

Can you water bath chicken broth or meat?

No. Meat, poultry, broth and seafood are low-acid and have pressure-canner times only.

Is a pressure cooker the same as a pressure canner?

No. The guide's times are tested in pressure canners that hold the jars and keep the pressure for the whole process; don't use them in another kind of appliance.

Jarwise: Canning Timer & Log

Canning app: USDA-tested times for your altitude, canner timer, jar log.

Jarwise has every tested food in the USDA guide. Set your altitude once and it shows the right time and pressure for your canner, with your altitude band highlighted; combinations the guide doesn't test get no time. A step-by-step timer covers venting, processing and cool-down, and a batch log and pantry keep track of your jars, offline and with no account.

Coming to Google Play

Sources

  1. USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning (2015), Introduction (Caution; For safety's sake) Introduction (PDF)
  2. USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning (2015), Guide 1: Principles of home canning (pages 1-8, 1-10, 1-13, 1-18 to 1-22) Guide 1 (PDF)
  3. USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning (2015), Guide 3: Tomatoes and tomato products (acidification, page 3-5) Guide 3 (PDF)
  4. USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning (2015), Guide 4: Vegetables and vegetable products Guide 4 (PDF)
  5. National Center for Home Food Preservation: the USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning, 2015 revision (current edition) nchfp.uga.edu

More guides

All guides